Part 1: Health Work sheet
Utilitarian Theory– The utilitarianism theory would ensure that the vaccine is administered to those at a higher chance of contracting the flu. However, caregivers may fail to consider people with terminal illness. Probably, they would be the last people to receive medication. Since it is vital to consider the greater good of the society, people who work towards economic growth would be one of the priority groups.
The rights-based theory – The theory would use the first come first served principle during the administration of the vaccine. Though the people behind the queue are in a dire need for the vaccine, they would not be immunized.
Duty-based ethics– The theory would imply that those who are already ill would be considered for treatment as compared to the healthy.
Justice-based– The theory would judge whether it is morally right to immunize people against the flu. Particularly, the theory examines the health implications of the process. For instance, healthy people are likely to contract the flue during the immunization procedures.
Virtue-based theory– The theorist would suggest that the healthcare givers should seek consent from the target population through a thorough explanation of the significance of the vaccination.
Part2: Principle Solution
Beneficence would be an ideal solution to the problem, as it ensures that the care givers engage the target population in the process of immunization. Both patient and healthy people have the right to consent and explanation on the reason for vaccination. Beneficence creates a room for consensus, where the interested parties come to a mutual understanding of issues. This principle promotes wellness and protects the community from any kind of harm, as health administrators determine the importance of the vaccination to the intended population.